A 2011-P Chickasaw quarter in gem MS condition has sold for $2,595 at auction — yet most pocket-change examples are worth just $0.25. Your quarter's value depends entirely on which of the five America the Beautiful designs you have, its mint mark, condition, and whether it carries a documented error. Use this free tool to find out in seconds.
The broad strike is the most dramatic — and most valuable — error type found on 2011 quarters. A coin struck without the retaining collar expands outward, producing an oversized diameter and a thin, spread rim. The 2011-D Chickasaw broad strike sold for $1,200 at Heritage Auctions in 2020. Use the quick checker below to see if your coin might qualify.
Run the 4-point check:
Not sure exactly what you have? Describe it in plain language and our analyzer will highlight the key value factors for your specific coin.
Skip straight to the calculator for an instant dollar estimate.
Select your design, mint mark, condition, and any known errors — then hit Calculate for an instant estimate.
If you're not yet sure about your coin's mint mark or condition, there's a 2011 Quarter Coin Value Checker tool that lets you upload a photo and get an AI-assisted identification before using this calculator.
Jump to any section of this guide:
Error coins from the 2011 America the Beautiful series can be worth far more than their face value — sometimes hundreds or thousands of dollars. Unlike attributed die varieties, these are one-off production mistakes that survived quality control. Each variety below has been confirmed by auction results from Heritage Auctions, GreatCollections, or PCGS-documented sales. Understanding what to look for can turn a pocket-change find into a significant discovery.
A broad strike error occurs when a planchet is struck outside the retaining collar — the cylindrical steel ring that normally constrains the coin and forms its reeded edge. Without that collar, the metal flows outward under the full force of the die strike, producing a coin that is measurably larger in diameter and thinner through the high points than a normal specimen.
On a 2011 quarter, a genuine broad strike will measure noticeably more than the standard 24.26 mm diameter. The rim appears thin, spread, or even partially absent on one or more sides, and design details near the periphery — Washington's legends on the obverse or the park's border inscriptions on the reverse — may show spread or distorted lettering. The reeding, if present at all, is irregular and flat.
Collector demand for dramatic broad strikes is strong because the visual impact is immediate and undeniable. Authentication by PCGS or NGC is essential: filed or sanded coins can superficially resemble broad strikes but lack the correct weight distribution and internal metal flow. A 2011-D Chickasaw quarter graded MS64 with a confirmed broad strike sold for $1,200 at Heritage Auctions in 2020, establishing the benchmark for this error on ATB quarters.
A die clash happens when the obverse and reverse dies come together at full striking force without a planchet between them. The impact transfers a mirror-image impression of each die's design onto the opposing die face. Every subsequent coin struck from those clashed dies will carry faint ghost images — called clash marks — from the opposite side of the coin pressed into the field or design elements.
On 2011 ATB quarters, die clash marks typically appear as faint incuse lines or ghostly design echoes in Washington's portrait field on the obverse, or in the open fields of the park design on the reverse. Strong clashes — where the die contact was severe enough to transfer bold, clearly readable features — are significantly more valuable than minor clash traces that require magnification to confirm. Look for reversed lettering, partial eagle or portrait echoes, or irregular raised lines in areas that should be flat.
The die state at the time of the clash affects value considerably. Early-state clash marks on well-preserved coins command the highest premiums because later strikes from the same clashed dies will show weakening of the transferred image as the die continues to wear. A 2011-D Vicksburg quarter graded MS65 with a die clash error realized $1,020 at Heritage Auctions in 2016, making this one of the documented standouts in the ATB error series.
A strike-through error occurs when a foreign object — grease, fabric fiber, wire, die debris, or another coin fragment — gets trapped between the die and the planchet at the moment of striking. The object absorbs part of the die's force, leaving a void, depression, or textured impression in the finished coin's surface wherever the obstruction was present. The struck-through area shows no design detail, creating a blank or textured void that contrasts sharply with the surrounding struck fields.
The visual impact of a strike-through depends entirely on what material was struck through and where it landed. Grease-filled die strike-throughs produce soft, mushy areas that lack detail but don't create deep voids. True struck-through errors — involving wire, cloth, or larger debris — produce recessed, often sharply edged voids with visible texture transfer. A strike-through landing on Washington's portrait or on the central park design element commands a premium over one located in an open field area with little design competition.
Strike-throughs are among the more collectible ATB quarter errors because the variety is visually striking, the identification is intuitive, and dramatic examples are genuinely scarce. Heritage Auctions sold a 2011-D Vicksburg quarter graded MS65 with a strike-through error for $540 in 2014, confirming strong collector demand for well-preserved examples on specific designs. Submission to PCGS or NGC not only authenticates the error type but also rules out post-mint damage.
An off-center strike happens when the planchet blank is not properly centered between the dies at the moment of impact. The die strikes only a portion of the planchet, leaving a characteristic crescent or wedge of unstruck, blank metal on one side. The resulting coin looks like it has been struck off to one side, with design elements crowded toward one edge and a smooth, unstruck arc on the opposite side.
Value for off-center strikes is directly tied to two factors: the percentage of offset and whether the date and mint mark remain fully visible. A coin that is 50% off-center but retains the complete date is worth considerably more than a 10% off-center example. Minor off-center strikes of 5–10% are modestly valuable at $5–$10, moderate examples at 20–30% fetch $25–$50, and major examples at 40%+ with visible date can bring $150 or more. A 2011-D Gettysburg quarter graded MS60 with an off-center strike has been documented in the error series.
Genuine off-center strikes are three-dimensional events — the coin will show compression on the struck side and the rim will be present only where the die contacted the planchet. Post-mint damage such as trimming or grinding can superficially mimic the look, but will not show the correct stress lines or edge characteristics. Always submit strong off-center examples to PCGS or NGC for authentication and proper error attribution on the holder label.
A cud is a specific type of die break in which a piece of the die fractures at or near the rim, leaving a void in the die face. When the damaged die continues to strike coins, the missing die area produces a raised, featureless blob of metal on each subsequent coin — since metal flows into the void in the die. The result is a raised, irregular lump at the rim that obliterates whatever design or lettering was adjacent to the break point.
Rim cuds are graded by size and the extent of design destruction. A small chip that only consumes a millimeter of the rim adds modest premium. A large cud that obliterates one or more letters of "LIBERTY," a date digit, or a significant element of the park design on the reverse is substantially more desirable. The die must have been significantly damaged — cuds are not simple surface marks, and the raised nature of the affected area is the diagnostic feature that distinguishes cuds from all forms of post-mint damage.
The rarity of rim cuds on ATB quarters makes them appealing to specialized error collectors. Heritage Auctions documented the sale of a 2011-D ATB quarter graded MS64 with a rim cud error for $640 in 2016, representing the top tier for this error type on 2011 issues. Smaller cuds bring $20–$75 depending on size and placement, while major cuds affecting key design elements command the highest premiums in the MS60–MS65 grade range.
Head back to the calculator, select your design and condition, then check the matching error box for an instant value range.
The table below covers all ten circulation designs (five × P and D) plus the San Francisco proof issues. For a deeper look at how each grade was determined, consult this illustrated 2011 quarter identification breakdown with grading guidance. Values represent typical market ranges based on PCGS auction data and dealer price guides as of 2026.
| Design | Mint | Worn (G–VF) | AU | Uncirculated (MS60–64) | Gem (MS65+) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gettysburg NMP | P | $0.25 | $0.75 – $1.35 | $1 – $5 | $5 – $35+ |
| Gettysburg NMP | D | $0.25 | $0.50 – $0.85 | $1 – $4 | $4 – $155+ |
| Glacier NP | P | $0.25 | $0.50 – $0.85 | $1 – $5 | $5 – $396+ |
| Glacier NP | D | $0.25 | $0.75 – $1.35 | $1 – $4 | $4 – $150+ |
| Olympic NP | P | $0.25 | $0.50 – $0.85 | $1 – $10 | $10 – $889+ |
| Olympic NP | D | $0.25 | $0.75 – $1.35 | $1 – $4 | $4 – $150+ |
| Vicksburg NMP | P | $0.25 | $0.75 – $1.35 | $1 – $5 | $5 – $188+ |
| Vicksburg NMP | D | $0.25 | $0.75 – $1.35 | $1 – $5 | $5 – $202+ |
| Chickasaw NRA ⭐ | P | $0.25 | $0.50 – $0.85 | $1 – $6 | $6 – $2,595+ |
| Chickasaw NRA | D | $0.25 | $0.75 – $1.35 | $1 – $4 | $4 – $120+ |
| Any design (S, clad proof) | S | — | — | — | $5 – $15 (PR69–70) |
| Any design (S, silver proof) | S | — | — | — | $14 – $71 (PR69–70) |
⭐ 2011-P Chickasaw is the top auction record holder at $2,595. Gold rows = key designs; red row = record holder.
🪙 CoinHix can identify your specific 2011 ATB design from a photo and cross-reference current market values in seconds — a coin identifier and value app.
All five 2011 ATB designs were struck at Philadelphia (P) and Denver (D) for general circulation, and at San Francisco (S) for proof sets only. The Chickasaw design received by far the highest total mintage — over 143 million combined — yet it paradoxically holds the top auction record in gem grade, illustrating that total mintage does not always predict collector-grade availability.
| Design | P Mintage | D Mintage | S Proof (Clad) | S Proof (Silver) | P+D Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gettysburg NMP | 30,800,000 | 30,400,000 | 1,271,553 | 722,076 | 61,200,000 |
| Glacier NP | 30,400,000 | 31,200,000 | 1,268,452 | 722,076 | 61,600,000 |
| Olympic NP | 30,400,000 | 30,600,000 | 1,267,361 | 722,076 | 61,000,000 |
| Vicksburg NMP | 30,800,000 | 33,400,000 | 1,267,691 | 722,076 | 64,200,000 |
| Chickasaw NRA | 73,800,000 | 69,400,000 | 1,266,010 | 722,076 | 143,200,000 |
| All 2011 designs (P+D) | 196,200,000 | 195,000,000 | ~6.34M total | ~3.61M total | 391,200,000 |
Source: Wikipedia America the Beautiful Quarter Mintage Figures (confirmed by CoinNews.net). Silver proof coins contain 0.182 oz ASW (90% silver). Clad circulating quarters are copper-nickel clad copper at 5.67 g, 24.26 mm, reeded edge.
The four key checkpoints on Washington quarters are: his cheek, the hair above and behind his ear, the high points of his crown, and the reverse's central design detail. These are the first areas to show wear and the most critical for grade assignment.
Washington's cheek is flat and smooth with no facial detail. Hair strands above the ear are merged into a flat mass. The reverse park design shows major outline only, with little interior relief. Worth face value.
Only the very highest points show a trace of wear — typically a faint flat spot on Washington's cheek or the top of his hair. Original luster covers 85–95% of the surface. Modest premium above face value.
No wear, but contact marks from bag handling are visible. Luster is complete. MS60–62 may have distracting marks; MS63–64 show only minor contact. Worth $1–$10 depending on design.
Only the lightest contact marks, none on Washington's face. Full, brilliant luster with a satiny or frosty cartwheel. MS67+ coins are virtually perfect. This is where major premiums begin — up to $2,595 for the top-pop Chickasaw.
📱 CoinHix lets you photograph your 2011 quarter and compare it against a database of graded examples to find your closest match — a coin identifier and value app.
Your selling venue should match your coin's value tier. Error coins and gem-grade specimens deserve professional audiences; common circulated quarters are not worth the effort of shipping.
The largest numismatic auction house in the world. Ideal for gem MS65+ coins, confirmed error coins worth $200+, and silver proof sets. They have the deepest buyer pool for serious ATB quarter collectors. Submit at least 3–4 months ahead of a major sale.
Best for MS63–65 coins and minor error varieties in the $10–$200 range. Check recently sold 2011 Glacier quarter prices and completed listings to price your coin competitively. Use the "Sold" filter in eBay search to see real market data before listing.
Convenient for quick cash, but expect 60–70 cents on the dollar for most coins. Bring your coin in a protective holder. A good LCS will give you a fair offer for common ATB quarters; for gem or error coins, get multiple offers first.
A free peer-to-peer marketplace where coin collectors buy directly from each other. No seller fees. Good for MS63–66 coins in the $5–$50 range. Post sharp photos and reference recent eBay comps for pricing credibility. Community-driven trust system.
Most circulated 2011 America the Beautiful quarters are worth only their face value of $0.25. Light wear brings modest premiums on some designs, ranging up to about $1. The Chickasaw and Olympic designs can fetch slightly more in AU condition due to lower collector survival rates, but the majority of circulated examples you find in pocket change are worth 25 cents.
In gem uncirculated MS grades, the 2011-P Chickasaw National Recreation Area quarter commands the highest premiums, with an auction record of $2,595 at PCGS-recognized sales. The 2011-P Olympic National Park quarter is the second most valuable regular-strike design, with auction records above $889. The Chickasaw design benefits from a lower collector-grade survival rate despite its higher total mintage.
The broad strike error is among the most dramatic and valuable. A 2011-D Chickasaw quarter graded MS64 with a broad strike sold for $1,200 at Heritage Auctions in 2020. Die clash errors also bring strong prices; a 2011-D Vicksburg quarter with a die clash sold for $1,020 at Heritage Auctions in 2016. Strike-through errors and off-center strikes round out the top tier.
Three mint marks appear on 2011 quarters. Philadelphia used the 'P' mark, Denver used 'D', and San Francisco used 'S' exclusively for proof and silver proof coins. The S-mint quarters were never released into general circulation. Business strike coins from P and D mints had mintages ranging from about 30 million each up to 73.8 million for the Chickasaw design from Philadelphia.
No authoritative doubled die varieties have been certified for 2011 ATB quarters by PCGS or NGC. Many examples sold online as 'DDO' or 'DDR' show mechanical doubling (also called machine doubling), which is a die-wear artifact with no numismatic premium. The Fivaz-Stanton Cherrypicker's Guide does not list any significant 2011 quarter doubled die varieties. Be skeptical of any seller claiming otherwise.
The 2011-S silver proof quarters were struck in 90% silver at the San Francisco Mint with a deep cameo (DCAM) proof finish — frosted raised design against mirror-like fields. Mintage was 722,076 for each design. In PR69 DCAM condition, these trade for roughly $14–$18; in perfect PR70 DCAM they can reach $17.50 to $71 depending on the design and label. The silver content (0.182 oz ASW) adds a base metal floor.
A broad strike error is identified by a larger-than-normal diameter and a thin, spread rim on one or more sides — the coin literally expanded outward when struck without a collar. Measure the diameter: a normal clad quarter is 24.26 mm. A broad-struck coin will exceed this measurement. The design elements are also spread or flattened near the edges. Confirm with a digital caliper and submit to PCGS or NGC for authentication before selling.
The total combined mintage of all circulating 2011 America the Beautiful quarters from Philadelphia and Denver was approximately 391,200,000. The five designs ranged from about 61 million combined (Gettysburg and Olympic) to over 143 million combined (Chickasaw). An additional 1.26–1.27 million clad proofs and 722,076 silver proofs were struck at San Francisco for each of the five designs.
Never clean a collectible coin. Cleaning removes the original surface and luster, permanently reducing its numismatic value by 50% or more. Even a gentle rinse with water can leave hairline scratches under magnification. Dealers and grading services immediately recognize cleaned coins and assign a 'Details' grade that dramatically lowers sale prices. If your 2011 quarter is in gem condition, submit it to PCGS or NGC as-is, in a protective flip or holder.
Look at the reverse design. Gettysburg shows a Pennsylvania infantry monument. Glacier features a mountain goat with Reynolds Mountain. Olympic depicts a Roosevelt elk at the Hoh River. Vicksburg shows the USS Cairo ironclad on the Yazoo River. Chickasaw shows a swimmer at the recreation area's natural swimming hole. The design name and state are inscribed around the reverse. The year appears on the obverse with the mint mark.
Use our free, instant calculator — no signup, no guesswork. Just select your design, mint mark, and condition.
Check My 2011 Quarter Value Now →